Beyond love at first sight, Max “inspired” Demi, the source added. As it happens, the Young and the Restless actor was a fan of Demi long before they got together. “All I wanted for Christmas was Demi Lovato,” Max tweeted in 2011, adding the hashtag “can’t always get what you want.”

Naturally, Demi couldn’t help but share the sweet throwback with her fans. “We love a little manifestation,” the Disney Channel alum captioned a screenshot of the tweet.

Sadly, these two weren’t meant to be. To see a timeline of Demi Lovato and Max Ehrich’s relationship, scroll through the gallery below.